How many Neurons for your 'Grandmother' ? Three Arguments for 'Localised' Representations
نویسندگان
چکیده
In a recent article, Bowers (2009) argues that local representations are more consistent with neuro-biological data than distributed representations, as typically generated in Parallel Distributed Processing (PDP) models. We present three reasons why localised neural representations are good candidates for supporting mental representations, as they provide a solution to the trade-off between combinatorial arguments that favour fully-distributed representations and metabolic arguments which favour localist representations.
منابع مشابه
Grandmother Cells and Distributed Representations
It is generally accepted that a typical visual stimulus will be represented by the activity of many millions of neurons distributed across many regions of the visual cortex. However, there is still a long-running debate about the extent to which information about individual objects and events can be read out from the responses of individual neurons. Is it conceivable that neurons could respond ...
متن کاملThe Encoding of Information in the Brain
The representation of objects and faces by neurons in the temporal lobe visual cortical areas of primates has the property that the neurons encode relatively independent information in their firing rates. This means that the number of stimuli that can be encoded increases exponentially with the number of neurons in an ensemble. Moreover, the information can be read by receiving neurons that per...
متن کاملUsing single unit recordings in PDP and localist models to better understand how knowledge is coded in the cortex
There is long history of studies documenting that some neurons respond to images of objects, faces, and scenes in a highly selective manner. This includes neurons in the human hippocampus (e.g., the famous example of a neuron responding to images of the actress Jennifer Aniston) and neurons in high-level visual cortex in monkey (for reviews see Bowers, 2009; Ison, Quian Quiroga, & Fried, 2015)....
متن کاملLocating object knowledge in the brain : A critique of Bowers ’ ( 2009 ) attempt to revive the grandmother cell hypothesis
According to Bowers (2009), the finding that there are neurons with highly selective responses to familiar stimuli supports theories positing localist representations over approaches positing distributed representations (including PDP models). However, his conclusions derive from an overly narrow view of the range of possible distributed representations and of the role that PDP models can play ...
متن کاملGnostic cells in the 21st century.
In this short review, I revise the notion of gnostic cells posited by Konorski, together with similar arguments by James, Lettvin and Barlow--namely, the idea of pontifical, grandmother and cardinal cells, respectively. I then discuss whether the characteristics of the recently discovered concept cells, i.e. neurons in the human medial temporal lobe with a very high degree of specificity and in...
متن کامل